Unlawful custody

Free case assessment
Are you entitled to compensation?
  • Contact us and we will help you
or call +420 773 014 007

Custody can put you behind bars before a court decides on your guilt. It is the most severe interference with personal liberty known to criminal proceedings. We explain when the state may take you into custody, when custody is unlawful, how long it may last and when the state will pay you compensation for it. If you or someone close to you ever ends up in a similar situation, you will know what to do.

Short answer

Custody is unlawful if there is no ground under Section 67 of the Criminal Procedure Code (risk of flight, of influencing witnesses or of continuing criminal activity), if its purpose could have been achieved by a milder measure, if the court did not decide on its continuation within 3 months at the latest, or if it exceeds the statutory maximum: 1 year for a misdemeanour, 2 years for a felony, 3 years for a particularly serious felony and 4 years if an exceptional sentence may be imposed (Section 72a).

The state will compensate you for custody even if it was justified at the time of the decision. It is enough that the prosecution against you was discontinued, you were acquitted or the case was referred to another authority (Section 9 of Act No. 82/1998 Coll.), and you do not fall under the exceptions in Section 12. You bring the claim on the Ministry of Justice form. A claim for satisfaction for non-material harm becomes time-barred after 6 months, a claim for damages after 3 years.

What custody is and what it is for

Custody may serve only the purposes laid down in the Criminal Procedure Code. The court will take you into custody only if your conduct or other specific facts give rise to a reasonable concern under Section 67. At the same time, the facts established so far must indicate that the act took place, has the features of a crime and was committed by you. And the purpose of custody cannot be achieved by another measure at the time of the decision.

Type of custody What the court is concerned about Criminal Procedure Code
Flight custody That you will flee or hide – especially if your identity cannot be established immediately, you have no permanent residence or you face a high sentence Section 67(a)
Collusion custody That you will influence witnesses or co-accused who have not yet been questioned, or otherwise obstruct the clarification of the case Section 67(b)
Preventive custody That you will repeat the criminal activity, complete a crime you attempted, or commit a crime you prepared or threatened Section 67(c)

Obstructing the investigation means, for example, influencing or intimidating witnesses or destroying key evidence – a weapon used in the crime or clothing with traces. Preventive custody also covers the situation where the crime remained at the stage of an attempt and there is a risk that the accused will complete it.

When custody is unlawful

Custody is unlawful if it does not comply with the conditions of the Criminal Procedure Code. The most common situations are these:

If none of the grounds under Section 67 exists or the court has not properly justified it, custody is unlawful. The same applies if the grounds for custody cease to exist during custody. The law enforcement authorities must continuously examine whether the grounds persist and must release the accused immediately once the ground for custody ceases. They must also release them if it is clear that the prosecution will not lead to an unconditional prison sentence (Section 71).

The crime is not serious enough

The court must not impose custody for less serious crimes. Under Section 68 of the Criminal Procedure Code, custody is generally not possible for intentional crimes with an upper limit of the sentence below two years or for negligent crimes with an upper limit of up to three years. However, the law provides exceptions – for example, if the accused has previously fled or hidden, repeatedly failed to appear when summoned, their identity cannot be established, or they have already influenced witnesses or otherwise obstructed the investigation.

Custody could have been replaced by a milder measure

In the case of flight and preventive custody, the court may leave the accused at liberty or release them if it accepts a guarantee from a trustworthy person or an interest association, a written promise from the accused, supervision by a probation officer, or imposes a preliminary measure (Section 73). At the same time it can order electronic monitoring or a travel ban. Custody is a last resort – if a milder measure is sufficient, custody is not appropriate.

Exceeding the maximum length of custody

Custody may last only as long as strictly necessary and never longer than set out in Section 72a. The maximum length depends on the seriousness of the crime you are being prosecuted for; with multiple crimes, the most severely punishable one is decisive. Of the total period, one third falls on the pre-trial proceedings and two thirds on the court proceedings. If the proceedings do not end within this period, you must be released on the last day of the time limit at the latest. Collusion custody may last no longer than three months, except where the accused has demonstrably already influenced witnesses.

Failure to meet the time limit for reviewing custody

The Criminal Procedure Code introduces a regular review of the necessity of custody. In pre-trial proceedings, a judge must decide at least every three months, on the public prosecutor’s proposal, whether to keep you in custody or release you. The public prosecutor must deliver the proposal to the court at least 15 days before the end of the time limit. After the indictment, the court must decide on custody within 30 days. If it fails to meet the time limit, it must release you immediately (Section 72).

Custody in figures: 3 months, 1 to 4 years, CZK 170

What Value Legal basis
Review of the continuation of custody At least every 3 months Section 72(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code
Decision on custody after the indictment Within 30 days Section 72(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code
Collusion custody No longer than 3 months Section 72a(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code
Maximum length of custody Misdemeanour 1 year, felony 2 years, particularly serious felony 3 years, with a possible exceptional sentence 4 years Section 72a(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code
Division of the maximum period 1/3 pre-trial proceedings, 2/3 court proceedings Section 72a(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code
Flat-rate lost profit CZK 170 for each day of custody started Section 30 of Act No. 82/1998 Coll.
Limitation of the claim Non-material harm 6 months, damage 3 years Section 32 of Act No. 82/1998 Coll.

Example: you are being prosecuted for a felony, so custody may last no longer than 2 years. In pre-trial proceedings it may last no longer than 8 months, before the court 16 months. The period is counted from the day your liberty was restricted. If after 200 days of custody the court acquits you and you do not prove lost earnings, you are entitled to at least 200 × CZK 170 = CZK 34,000. The state will compensate proven earnings in their actual amount. A complete overview of the time limits can be found in our article on the maximum time limits for restricting personal liberty.

Conditions for a claim to compensation for custody

To claim compensation, you must meet these conditions:

  1. Custody ended with an outcome under Section 9 – the prosecution against you was discontinued, you were acquitted or the case was referred to another authority. You do not need the custody decision itself to be annulled.
  2. You suffered damage or non-material harm – lost earnings, defence costs, psychological harm, damaged reputation.
  3. Causal link – the damage is linked to the custody, not to other circumstances.

In addition to custody, you can also claim compensation for the prosecution itself – defence costs or damage to your reputation. Details can be found in our article on unlawful criminal prosecution.

The state’s liability for custody therefore depends on the outcome of the prosecution, not on whether the authorities made a mistake. If you are ultimately convicted and the court counts the custody towards your sentence, no claim under Section 9 arises. It is different for custody that was unlawful from the outset or lasted longer than the law allows – there, liability for an unlawful decision may come into consideration, but the assessment is more complex. The general rules of state liability are summarised in our guide to damage caused by the state.

Compensation for unlawful custody

The state is liable to you for custody that did not end in a conviction and for an unlawful decision on custody. Custody often damages your reputation at work and in private life. Compensation therefore includes not only lost earnings, but also satisfaction for psychological harm and the impact on your social standing.

Item What it includes
Lost earnings Wages or business income for the period of custody; without proof at least CZK 170 per day (Section 30)
Defence costs Reasonable costs of a defence lawyer under the attorneys’ tariff (Section 31)
Other provable costs For example, travel expenses connected with the defence
Non-material harm Interference with personal liberty, stress and anxiety, loss of trust in justice, damaged reputation, separation from family and friends

Loss of a job or business opportunities is financial damage – prove it as lost earnings or lost profit. How to bring the claim step by step, including the ministry form, is described in our article on compensation for detention, arrest and custody. Whether you pay tax on compensation is explained in our article on taxation of compensation for non-material harm.

What to do so that you do not lose your compensation

  1. Defend yourself already during custody. File a complaint against the custody decision within the time limit stated in the instructions and ask to be released as soon as the grounds cease.
  2. Propose a milder measure. A guarantee, a written promise, supervision by a probation officer or a preliminary measure.
  3. Watch the time limits. The three-month review, 30 days after the indictment and the maximum length of custody.
  4. Keep all decisions. On taking you into custody, on its continuation, on your release and the decision that ended the prosecution.
  5. Prove your lost earnings. Payslips, a confirmation from your employer, tax returns – otherwise you will receive only the flat rate.
  6. Bring your claim on the form within 6 months. The ministry will not assess an application to the Ministry of Justice submitted in any other way (Section 14(6)).
  7. If the claim is not fully satisfied within 6 months, file an action (Section 15(2)).

Why the state reduces or refuses compensation for custody

The ministry most often argues that you caused the custody yourself – by fleeing, hiding, influencing witnesses or making a false confession. It will also refuse the claim if you were acquitted only because of insanity, because of a pardon or amnesty, in the case of conditional discontinuance of prosecution, a settlement, or if the court counted the custody towards your sentence (Section 12). For non-material harm, it often offers a low amount or only an apology, and disputes also arise about when the six-month time limit begins. We pursue compensation for damage caused by the state with you from filling in the form all the way to court. How we have helped others can be found in our references.

How we can help

Unlawful custody is a serious interference with your fundamental rights. If it has affected you, defend yourself and seek justice. You will succeed if you act quickly, have thorough documentation and proceed strategically. We assess your case free of charge, and you pay our fee only from the compensation recovered – more on the page what our service costs.

Submit your case online – the form takes just a few minutes. The next steps are described on the page how it works.

Frequently asked questions

Am I entitled to compensation for custody if I was acquitted?

Yes. Under Section 9 of Act No. 82/1998 Coll., you have a claim if you were acquitted, the prosecution was discontinued or the case was referred to another authority. It does not matter whether the custody was justified at the time of the decision. The exceptions are set out in Section 12.

How long can custody last?

In total, no longer than 1 year for a misdemeanour, 2 years for a felony, 3 years for a particularly serious felony and 4 years if an exceptional sentence may be imposed. One third falls on the pre-trial proceedings, two thirds on the court proceedings. Collusion custody may last no longer than 3 months.

How often does the court review whether custody is still justified?

In pre-trial proceedings, at least every 3 months. After the indictment, the court must decide within 30 days and then again at least every 3 months. If it fails to meet the time limit, it must release you.

Can the court replace custody with something milder?

Yes, in the case of flight and preventive custody. The court can accept a guarantee from a trustworthy person, your written promise, supervision by a probation officer or impose a preliminary measure, possibly with electronic monitoring.

How much will I get for each day in custody?

Lost earnings in the proven amount. If they cannot be proven, you are entitled to CZK 170 for each day of custody started. In addition, you claim reasonable satisfaction for non-material harm.

When am I not entitled to compensation for custody?

If you caused the custody yourself, if you were acquitted only because of insanity, because of a pardon or amnesty, in the case of conditional discontinuance of prosecution or a settlement, and if the court counted the period of custody towards the sentence imposed.

More interesting posts from this section

Limitation of a compensation claim: time limits

Limitation of a compensation claim: time limits

A claim for compensation is not valid forever. If you do not bring it in time, the wrongdoer or their insurer will raise a limitation defence and the court will not award you compensation – even if you are right about everything else. And the period runs even when nothing seems to be happening: during treatment, while corresponding with the insurer or while waiting for a criminal judgment. What you can claim from the wrongdoer is summarised in the overview of claims for harm to health.

Annuity after an injury

Annuity after an injury

Your incapacity for work has ended, but after the injury you will not return to your former job – or only part-time, for lower pay or with a strain you never knew before. The wrongdoer usually does not make up the difference in one payment: the Civil Code provides for this loss with a regular monthly payment, an annuity. Over ten or twenty years it may even exceed pain and suffering, yet injured people often lose it – for example by signing a settlement “in full”.

Reference

Marek S.
I suffered an accident at work and it was only through legal aid that I was able to find out what I could claim from my employer. I therefore claimed from my employer for reimbursement of medical expenses, compensation for wages during incapacity for work and a subsequent annuity. My employer also paid me severance pay, which I never thought would be such a large sum.
Daniel N.
I contacted this company for help. I thought I was entitled to severance pay due to my medical condition and occupational illness, but my employer claimed I was not entitled to anything. Fortunately, I didn't take their arrogance lying down, and thanks to their help, they paid me severance pay and are still paying me an annuity due to my occupational illness. Thank you very much.
Petr H.
Thank you for your service and help in a difficult situation with my employer. I have dealt with unpaid compensation from my employer when travelling abroad for work. In the end we resolved everything. Thanks for your help, willingness, determination, and most importantly motivation to not give up just out of fear of being in a weaker position.
Jana S.
I got fired when I was pregnant at the time. I thought that was a valid notice. Fortunately, I took advice on the situation and was not left destitute and unsecured, thank you so much for your human touch, empathy and discretion in handling the whole matter.
Martin F.
Thank you so much for helping me with a problem at work. It was about the payment of wage compensation during and after the treatment period. If it wasn't for you, I wouldn't have known I was entitled to anything like that. I am glad I sought information and chose your services. I don't wish anyone to experience such things, but if you already run into some problems, don't hesitate to choose the help of professionals, they are the people in their place.
    Advokátní kancelář Šmarda s.r.o.

    Jindrisska
    Masarykova třída 922/8, Prague

    Do not miss anything important

    Sign up for our newsletter