Damage caused by the state: a complete guide to state liability for damage

Free case assessment
Are you entitled to compensation?
  • Contact us and we will help you
or call +420 773 014 007

Wondering what to do when the state causes you damage? Compensation for unlawful interference by the state is one of the foundations of a democratic society. This guide explains when the state is liable for damage, what you can claim from it and how to bring your claim so that you do not miss the very short time limits.

Short answer

The state is liable for damage caused to you by an unlawful decision or by maladministration – including delays in proceedings, inaction of an authority, unlawful custody or a criminal prosecution that ends in acquittal. Liability is strict: you do not have to prove fault on the part of the official. The rules are set out in Act No. 82/1998 Coll., and the claim has a constitutional basis in Article 36(3) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms.

You first bring your claim before the competent ministry – for courts and criminal matters, the Ministry of Justice. You can sue only if the state does not satisfy your claim in full within 6 months. Watch the time limits: a claim for damages becomes time-barred after 3 years, and a claim for satisfaction for non-material harm after just 6 months from when you learn of the harm.

What damage caused by the state is

Damage caused by the state is harm caused to you by the state or its bodies in the exercise of public power – a court, an authority, the police, the public prosecutor’s office, but also a notary or a court bailiff. The claim is based on fundamental rights and freedoms and is expressly guaranteed by the Charter. However, its conditions and procedure are considerably narrowed by a special law, Act No. 82/1998 Coll., on liability for damage caused in the exercise of public power by a decision or maladministration. It determines when, where and by when you claim compensation from the state.

When the state becomes liable for damage

In simple terms: the state is liable when it exercises its powers contrary to the law and you suffer damage or other harm as a result. You must prove three things:

  • a failure by the state – an unlawful decision or maladministration (Section 5 of the Act),
  • damage or non-material harm – a decrease in your assets, lost profit, stress, damaged reputation,
  • a causal link – the damage occurred precisely because of the state’s failure, not because of another prevailing cause.

You do not have to prove fault on the part of a specific official or judge. The state’s liability is strict and it cannot escape it.

Situations in which the state is liable for damage

Failure by the state Typical example Key condition Act No. 82/1998 Coll.
Unlawful decision An authority bans your activity and the appellate body annuls the decision A final decision annulled or changed as unlawful Section 5(a), Sections 7 and 8
Maladministration A lost file, an incorrect entry, incorrect instructions Conduct contrary to the law; no decision needs to be annulled Section 5(b), Section 13
Inaction An authority does not issue a decision within the statutory time limit Breach of the duty to act within the statutory time limit Section 13(1), second sentence
Delays in proceedings A court case lasts ten years Breach of the duty to decide within a reasonable time Section 13(1), third sentence, Section 31a(3)
Custody You are held in custody and the prosecution then ends in acquittal Discontinuance of the prosecution, acquittal or referral of the case Section 9
Criminal prosecution The prosecution of an innocent person ends in acquittal or discontinuance Acquittal or discontinuance of the prosecution; exceptions are set out in Section 12 Section 5(a), Sections 7 and 8

Unlawful decision

The law regards as an unlawful decision a final decision that the competent body has annulled or changed as unlawful. The claim belongs to the parties to the proceedings who suffered damage from the decision, as well as to anyone whom the authority should have treated as a party but did not (Section 7). Beware of Section 8(3): except in cases deserving special consideration, the state will compensate you only if you used all procedural remedies in time – an appeal, an appellate review, a cassation complaint and others, except an application to reopen the proceedings.

Maladministration

Maladministration covers failures that do not result in a decision: loss of or damage to a file, an incorrect entry in a register, incorrect instructions, a disproportionate police intervention. Here the damage is caused by the authority’s conduct itself, not by its decision, and no decision needs to be annulled. Special forms of maladministration are delays in proceedings and inaction of an authority – the authority does not decide within the statutory or a reasonable time limit.

Unlawful criminal prosecution

This is a criminal prosecution that the state conducted against an innocent person. When the prosecution ends in acquittal or discontinuance, the state has interfered with your fundamental rights and you usually have a claim for compensation. The exceptions are set out in Section 12 of the Act – you have no claim, for example, if you caused the prosecution yourself. Details can be found in our article on compensation for unlawful criminal prosecution.

Unlawful detention, arrest and custody

Deprivation of liberty is the state’s most serious interference with your rights. The state is liable to you for custody if it discontinued the prosecution against you, acquitted you or referred the case to another authority (Section 9). How to defend yourself against unlawful detention or arrest is discussed separately.

How to bring a claim for compensation for damage caused by the state

The procedure has two mandatory stages. Without the first, the court will not hear you at all.

Stage Where What applies
1. Preliminary assessment The Ministry of Justice (courts, criminal proceedings, notaries, bailiffs); otherwise the ministry or central authority whose competence the matter falls under; if it cannot be determined, the Ministry of Finance A condition for an action (Section 14(3)). An authority without competence will forward the application and its effects are preserved (Section 14(2)). Claims for custody and sentences only on the ministry form (Section 14(6)).
2. Court proceedings The locally competent court; the authority from the first stage acts for the state You can sue if the authority does not satisfy the claim in full within 6 months (Section 15(2)). You prove the damage, its amount and the causal link.

The preliminary assessment gives the state the opportunity to pay without going to court. In practice, however, the state often insists on court proceedings and the dispute drags on for years.

What you can claim from the state

Item What it includes
Actual damage How much your assets decreased
Lost profit What you would have earned if the state had not failed
Costs of proceedings Reasonable costs of having the decision annulled or the conduct remedied, including an attorney at the statutory tariff (Section 31)
Satisfaction for non-material harm Money for stress, damaged reputation or family life, if a finding of a violation of rights is not enough (Section 31a)
Default interest If the state does not pay on time

Whether you pay tax on the compensation awarded is discussed in our article on taxation of compensation for non-material harm.

Example 1 – delays in administrative proceedings: an authority unjustifiably prolongs the proceedings on your application. In addition to damages, you can claim satisfaction for the unreasonable length of the proceedings. The European Court of Human Rights regards the unreasonable length of proceedings as a violation of the right to a fair trial.

Example 2 – unlawful criminal prosecution: the prosecution against you ends in acquittal. You claim from the state compensation for damage including lost profit and satisfaction for non-material harm.

Time limits in figures: 6 months, 3 years, 10 years

Time limits are the most common reason why people lose compensation from the state. Watch the shortest one first – six months for non-material harm.

Time limit Length and start Provision
Handling by the authority 6 months from bringing the claim Section 15(1) and (2)
Limitation of a claim for damages 3 years from learning of the damage and of who is liable for it; for an unlawful decision, from delivery of the annulling decision Section 32(1)
Objective time limit for an unlawful decision 10 years from delivery of the unlawful decision (does not apply to damage to health) Section 32(2)
Limitation of a claim for non-material harm 6 months from learning of the harm, at most 10 years; for delays, not earlier than 6 months after the proceedings end Section 32(3)
Suspension of limitation During the preliminary assessment, for at most 6 months Section 35(1)

Example: the appellate body annulled an unlawful decision and delivered the annulling decision to you on 2 March 2026. The limitation period for lost profit ends on 2 March 2029; it does not run while the ministry is assessing the claim (at most 6 months), so it is extended by that period. However, bring your claim for satisfaction for non-material harm within six months of learning of the harm – otherwise the state will plead the statute of limitations.

What to do so that you do not lose your compensation

  1. Use all available remedies. Without an appeal or an appellate review, the state will usually not compensate damage caused by an unlawful decision (Section 8(3)).
  2. Fight delays already during the proceedings. In court, file an application for setting a time limit for a procedural step; with an authority, a request for measures against inaction. The court then takes into account whether you used them (Section 31a(3)(c)).
  3. Collect documentation. Copies of the file, correspondence with the authority, decisions including proof of delivery.
  4. Quantify the damage and prove the causal link. Invoices, contracts, tax returns, an expert opinion for lost profit.
  5. Submit the application to the right authority. For custody and sentences, use the Ministry of Justice form, otherwise the application will be disregarded.
  6. Watch the six months. A claim for satisfaction for non-material harm becomes time-barred much earlier than a claim for damages.
  7. After six months, consider an action. If the authority does not pay your claim in full, waiting longer will get you nothing.

Why the state reduces or refuses compensation

Ministries most often argue that the damage was caused by another prevailing cause, that you did not use the available remedies, that you contributed to the delays yourself, or that a finding of a violation of rights is sufficient satisfaction for you. You can refute each of these if you have documents and a correctly quantified claim. The Constitutional Court has repeatedly pointed out that courts must not place an impossible burden of proof on claimants – otherwise the right to compensation under Article 36(3) of the Charter would be merely illusory.

Bear in mind also that the state will not reimburse the costs of an attorney representing you while the ministry is assessing the claim (Section 31(4)). That is why we pursue compensation for damage caused by the state with you in a way that you do not bear the risk alone – from the preliminary assessment all the way to court.

The rights of the injured party

State liability for damage protects you against unlawful conduct by state bodies. You will succeed if you follow the statutory procedure and time limits and support your claim with evidence. We will help you assess whether and how much to claim from the state. We assess your case free of charge, and you pay our fee only from the compensation recovered – details can be found on the page what our service costs.

Submit your case online – the form takes just a few minutes. What happens next is described on the page how it works.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to prove that the official or judge acted intentionally?

No. The state’s liability is strict, regardless of fault. You prove the state’s failure, the damage or non-material harm and the causal link between them.

Where do I bring a claim for compensation from the state?

With the authority under Section 6 of Act No. 82/1998 Coll. If the damage occurred in court or in criminal proceedings, with the Ministry of Justice. In administrative matters, with the ministry or central authority whose competence the matter falls under. If you submit the application to an authority without competence, it will forward it to the correct one and the effects of the claim are preserved.

How long do I have to bring my claim?

A claim for damages becomes time-barred 3 years from learning of the damage and the liable party. A claim for satisfaction for non-material harm after just 6 months. The limitation period does not run during the preliminary assessment, but for no longer than 6 months.

When can I sue the state?

Only after the preliminary assessment. You file an action if the authority does not satisfy your claim in full within 6 months of bringing it. The same authority then acts for the state in court.

Is the state also liable for a police intervention?

Yes. A disproportionate intervention by the police, customs officers or other armed forces can also be maladministration. If the police acted in criminal proceedings, you bring the claim with the Ministry of Justice; otherwise usually with the Ministry of the Interior.

Will I get my attorney’s costs back?

Yes, for the costs you reasonably incurred in having the unlawful decision annulled or the conduct remedied, including an attorney at the statutory tariff (Section 31). However, the state will not reimburse the costs of representation while the ministry is assessing the claim (Section 31(4)).

More interesting posts from this section

Limitation of a compensation claim: time limits

Limitation of a compensation claim: time limits

A claim for compensation is not valid forever. If you do not bring it in time, the wrongdoer or their insurer will raise a limitation defence and the court will not award you compensation – even if you are right about everything else. And the period runs even when nothing seems to be happening: during treatment, while corresponding with the insurer or while waiting for a criminal judgment. What you can claim from the wrongdoer is summarised in the overview of claims for harm to health.

Annuity after an injury

Annuity after an injury

Your incapacity for work has ended, but after the injury you will not return to your former job – or only part-time, for lower pay or with a strain you never knew before. The wrongdoer usually does not make up the difference in one payment: the Civil Code provides for this loss with a regular monthly payment, an annuity. Over ten or twenty years it may even exceed pain and suffering, yet injured people often lose it – for example by signing a settlement “in full”.

Reference

Marek S.
I suffered an accident at work and it was only through legal aid that I was able to find out what I could claim from my employer. I therefore claimed from my employer for reimbursement of medical expenses, compensation for wages during incapacity for work and a subsequent annuity. My employer also paid me severance pay, which I never thought would be such a large sum.
Daniel N.
I contacted this company for help. I thought I was entitled to severance pay due to my medical condition and occupational illness, but my employer claimed I was not entitled to anything. Fortunately, I didn't take their arrogance lying down, and thanks to their help, they paid me severance pay and are still paying me an annuity due to my occupational illness. Thank you very much.
Petr H.
Thank you for your service and help in a difficult situation with my employer. I have dealt with unpaid compensation from my employer when travelling abroad for work. In the end we resolved everything. Thanks for your help, willingness, determination, and most importantly motivation to not give up just out of fear of being in a weaker position.
Jana S.
I got fired when I was pregnant at the time. I thought that was a valid notice. Fortunately, I took advice on the situation and was not left destitute and unsecured, thank you so much for your human touch, empathy and discretion in handling the whole matter.
Martin F.
Thank you so much for helping me with a problem at work. It was about the payment of wage compensation during and after the treatment period. If it wasn't for you, I wouldn't have known I was entitled to anything like that. I am glad I sought information and chose your services. I don't wish anyone to experience such things, but if you already run into some problems, don't hesitate to choose the help of professionals, they are the people in their place.
    Advokátní kancelář Šmarda s.r.o.

    Jindrisska
    Masarykova třída 922/8, Prague

    Do not miss anything important

    Sign up for our newsletter