Medical Malpractice and Compensation
Medical malpractice can have serious consequences for a patient. Czech law provides victims with the possibility to seek compensation for damages and non-material harm. This article explains how such compensation can be obtained, what it may include, and the conditions necessary for successful enforcement.
What is Medical Malpractice?
In legal terms, medical malpractice refers to a procedure or conduct by a healthcare professional that is not in accordance with current scientific knowledge and accepted medical practices (known as non lege artis). To determine whether malpractice occurred, the relevant standard is the level of medical knowledge and practice at the time the care was provided.
Common cases of medical errors include:
- Incorrect or delayed diagnosis
- Selection of an inappropriate treatment method
- Errors during surgical or medical procedures
- Prescription mistakes (wrong medication or dosage)
- Inadequate postoperative care
- Unauthorized procedures (without informed consent)
- Poor communication among healthcare providers
It is important to note that not every unfavorable outcome of treatment constitutes malpractice. Medicine is not an exact science, and complications or treatment failures may occur even when standard procedures are properly followed.
Legal Framework for Liability in Medical Malpractice
Liability for damages caused during the provision of healthcare services is primarily regulated by:
- The Civil Code (Act No. 89/2012 Coll.)
- The Healthcare Services Act (Act No. 372/2011 Coll.)
- The Act on Specific Healthcare Services (Act No. 373/2011 Coll.)
- The Criminal Code (Act No. 40/2009 Coll.)
Legally, healthcare providers are subject to strict (objective) liability, meaning the patient does not need to prove fault (intent or negligence). The provider can avoid liability only by proving so-called liberating reasons, particularly that the harm could not have been prevented even with the exercise of all reasonable effort.
Conditions for Compensation in Medical Malpractice
To successfully claim compensation, the following conditions must be met:
- Unlawful Conduct (non lege artis)
- There must be a breach of a legal duty, which in healthcare means failing to follow standard procedures (lege artis) or other duties, such as confidentiality or proper patient information.
- Occurrence of Harm
- The patient must suffer harm, which can be material (financial loss) or non-material (pain, reduced social functioning, psychological suffering).
- Causal Link
- There must be a causal connection between the unlawful conduct and the resulting harm. Establishing this link is often the most challenging aspect, as complications may have multiple causes.
Compensation for Material Damage
Material damage may include:
- Actual costs – e.g., additional treatment not covered by health insurance, co-payments for medication, medical aids, caregiver costs, home modifications due to new health conditions
- Loss of earnings – during incapacity for work and after if reduced working ability persists
- Loss of pension benefits – if the health damage reduces the basis for calculating pension entitlements
Compensation for Non-Material Damage
Non-material damage includes:
- Pain and suffering – compensation for pain caused by health damage and its treatment
- Reduced social functioning – compensation for permanent consequences limiting the victim’s daily life
- Other non-material harm – e.g., fear, anxiety, stress, loss of joy in life
Compensation in Case of Death
If a patient dies as a result of medical malpractice, the survivors are entitled to:
- Reimbursement of funeral costs
- Reimbursement of maintenance costs for dependents if the deceased had a duty to support them
- One-time compensation for emotional distress for the spouse, children, parents, and other close relatives
Procedure for Claiming Compensation:
- Obtain Medical Documentation
- The first step is to obtain complete medical records. The patient has the right to a copy under § 65 of the Healthcare Services Act. It is advisable to have the documentation reviewed by an independent expert.
- File a Complaint
- Before legal action, file a complaint:
- Directly with the healthcare provider
- With the relevant professional chamber (Czech Medical Chamber)
- With the regional authority for administrative oversight
- With the health insurance company
- Out-of-Court Settlement
- It is possible to attempt an out-of-court agreement with the provider or their insurer, which is usually faster and less expensive.
- Pre-Litigation Notice
- Before filing a lawsuit, send a pre-litigation notice requesting voluntary fulfillment under § 142a of the Civil Procedure Code. This is also important for potential reimbursement of legal costs.
- Lawsuit for Compensation
- If the dispute is not resolved out of court, file a lawsuit in the competent district court. An expert report demonstrating malpractice should be attached.
- Criminal Complaint
- In cases of severe negligence, consider filing a criminal complaint, e.g., for suspected bodily harm caused by negligence.
Liability Insurance for Healthcare Providers
Healthcare providers are legally required to have liability insurance for damages caused during the provision of healthcare. This means that in a successful claim, compensation is paid by the provider’s insurer, not from the provider’s personal funds.
Summary
Claiming compensation for medical malpractice is a complex process requiring knowledge of the legal framework, patience, and often significant financial resources. Nevertheless, it is important for affected patients to actively assert their rights – not only for personal satisfaction but also to contribute to improving healthcare quality and safety.
Key to success is timely and proper collection of evidence, especially medical documentation and expert reports, and adherence to all legal deadlines. In more complex cases, it is advisable to consult a lawyer specializing in medical law, who can evaluate the chances of success and propose the optimal approach.
Contact Poškozený
📞 By phone: +420 773 014 007
📧 By e-mail: info@poskozeny.cz
🏢 Via the contact form: formuláře