You waited a long time for a decision on compensation and the result disappointed you. The amount the insurer awarded does not match what you went through and lost because of your injury. But a low offer is not the final verdict. We show you what the insurer must explain to you, where it most often cuts and how to defend yourself – from a request for review all the way to an action.
Short answer
You do not have to accept low compensation from an insurer. Under compulsory motor insurance, within 3 months of your claim the insurer must tell you the amount of compensation for each claim separately and how it was calculated, or explain in writing why it rejected or reduced the claim (Section 2798 of the Civil Code). This explanation is the starting point of your defence.
Compare the offer with the Supreme Court Methodology: for a health condition stabilised in 2026, a pain point is usually worth CZK 492.15, and loss of amenity is calculated as a percentage of 400 times the average wage. Then submit new evidence or your own expert opinion and ask for a review. If the insurer does not budge, send it a demand for payment and file an action – you pay no court fee for an action for compensation for injury to health.
Why the insurer offered you little
Incorrect assessment of the extent of the damage
Insurers assess claims according to internal rules and procedures. These may underestimate the real extent of your harm or overlook some of its consequences – typically future medical costs, loss of earnings after sick leave ends or the care your family provides. Everything you can claim from the wrongdoer is summarised in our overview of the injured party’s claims for injury to health.
Exclusions and contributory fault
The insurer is a commercial entity and will examine whether it can classify your situation under an insurance exclusion or attribute part of the blame to you. If you contributed to the harm or its increase, the wrongdoer will compensate you only proportionately (Section 2918 of the Civil Code). However, the share of contributory fault must correspond to how the accident actually happened, and the insurer must justify it.
Undervalued non-material harm
Pain, mental suffering and loss of amenity often make up the largest part of compensation – and are also the most frequent subject of disputes. The insurer may assign fewer points, use an incorrect point value or ignore permanent consequences altogether. How pain and suffering is calculated correctly is explained in our article on pain and suffering compensation.
What the insurer must tell you and by when
For damage from traffic accidents covered by the at-fault driver’s compulsory motor insurer, the rules are set out in Act No. 30/2024 Coll. An overview of the insurer’s obligations:
| Insurer’s obligation |
Time limit and content |
Legal basis |
| Investigation of the claim |
Without undue delay |
Section 2798 of the Civil Code |
| Notification of the amount of compensation |
Within 3 months of the claim, for each claim separately including the method of calculation |
Section 2798 of the Civil Code |
| Written explanation |
Within 3 months for claims that are rejected, reduced or not yet investigated |
Section 2798 of the Civil Code |
| Payment of compensation |
Within 15 days of the end of the investigation or of delivery of a final judgment |
Section 2797 of the Civil Code |
| Missing the 3-month time limit |
You can report the missed time limit to the Czech National Bank; once compensation is due, default interest is payable |
Section 86 of Act No. 30/2024 Coll. |
| Parallel criminal proceedings |
The investigation must not be made conditional on the end of the criminal proceedings |
Section 29 of Act No. 30/2024 Coll. |
Check whether the insurer stated the amount and method of calculation for each item. If it gave you only a total sum, ask for a breakdown – without it, you cannot see where it cut.
The insurer also must not postpone its investigation merely because criminal proceedings are running against the at-fault driver (Section 29 of Act No. 30/2024 Coll.). If it replies that it will wait for the judgment, point out this obligation. In addition, you can bring your claims gradually: pain and suffering and medical costs after treatment ends, loss of amenity only after your health condition stabilises. You will thus receive the first money before the expert assesses the permanent consequences.
Model example: after a traffic accident, your health condition stabilises in 2026. The insurer offers you pain and suffering for 120 points at CZK 451.07, i.e. CZK 54,128 – it used the point value applicable in 2025 for work injuries. Under the Supreme Court Methodology, for a condition stabilised in 2026 a point is usually worth CZK 492.15 and pain and suffering amounts to CZK 59,058. A much bigger difference arises with permanent consequences. If the insurer assessed them in points (for example 300 points × CZK 451.07 = CZK 135,321), it would be acting outside the Methodology, which is based on the percentage by which the consequences limit you. With a 5% limitation, the basic amount is CZK 984,300 (5% of CZK 19,686,000) and, for a thirty-year-old injured person, after a 20% adjustment roughly CZK 1,181,160. The detailed calculation can be found in our article on loss of amenity.
How to defend yourself step by step
1. Ask for a review with new evidence
Write to the insurer stating what you disagree with and why. Without new documents, the insurer will usually not change its decision. Attach:
- new evidence of the extent of the harm – medical reports from later treatment, rehabilitation, complications,
- an expert opinion or professional statement – your own independent assessment of the injury and its consequences,
- a calculation under the Supreme Court Methodology – with the point value for the year in which your health condition stabilised,
- a breakdown of all costs – receipts, invoices, proof of income before and after the accident.
2. Have your own expert opinion prepared
The insurer relies on its own assessment. An independent expert may arrive at a different number of points or a higher percentage of limitation. Focus the opinion on:
- the correct assessment of all injuries according to the medical records,
- the use of the Supreme Court Methodology and the correct point value,
- items the original assessment ignored altogether – for example psychological consequences or complications of treatment.
3. Send a demand for payment and file an action
If the insurer does not budge, you have the right to seek the outstanding amount in court. At least 7 days before filing the action, send the insurer a demand for payment, otherwise the court will award you the costs of the proceedings only exceptionally (Section 142a of the Code of Civil Procedure). You pay no court fee for an action for compensation for injury to health or for harm caused by death (Section 11(2)(d) of the Court Fees Act). How long to expect the dispute to take is discussed in our article on how long proceedings for compensation take.
The insurer’s most common arguments and how to answer them
| Insurer’s argument |
Your answer |
Evidence |
| The points assessment matches the expert report |
The report did not include all injuries or complications of treatment |
Complete medical records, your own expert opinion |
| The point value is correct |
For injuries outside work, the Supreme Court Methodology applies according to the year of stabilisation, not the value for work injuries |
Calculation under the Methodology |
| Permanent consequences have not been proven |
You claim loss of amenity after your condition stabilises |
Medical report on stabilisation, expert opinion |
| Contributory fault, for example not wearing a seat belt |
The share must correspond to how the conduct affected the extent of the injury |
Police file, expert opinion on the injury mechanism |
| Future costs are not certain |
You prove them with a doctor’s recommendation and a budget |
Doctor’s recommendation, price quotes |
| Loss of earnings only for the period of sick leave |
After sick leave ends, you are entitled to a monetary pension if you earn less (Section 2963 of the Civil Code) |
Proof of income before and after the accident |
Watch out in particular for future costs: long-term rehabilitation, psychological care, home adaptations or assistive devices. If you have been left with permanent consequences, read our article on compensation for permanent consequences after an injury too.
What to do so that you do not lose your compensation
- Do not sign a settlement under pressure. A settlement agreement may also cover claims you do not yet know about.
- Ask for a written justification. The insurer must provide it for each rejected or reduced claim.
- Keep all documents. Medical reports, receipts, proof of income, photographs of injuries.
- Recalculate pain and suffering. Use the point value for the year in which your health condition stabilised.
- Claim permanent consequences separately. After your condition stabilises, ask for an additional payment for loss of amenity.
- Watch the limitation period. The claim becomes time-barred 3 years from when you learn of the harm and the liable person.
- Send a demand for payment before an action. At least 7 days in advance.
When the insurer is right to reduce compensation and when a dispute is worth it
Not every reduction is a mistake. If you contributed to the accident yourself or did not prove part of the costs, the insurer may justifiably reduce compensation. What matters is whether it justified the reduction and whether it matches the evidence. A dispute is worth it mainly when the insurer used the wrong point value, assessed permanent consequences in points instead of a percentage, ignored loss of earnings after sick leave ended, or attributed contributory fault to you without support in the file.
Think about time too: negotiations with the insurer do not in themselves stop the limitation period. It does not run only if you expressly agree with the insurer on out-of-court negotiations about the claim (Section 647 of the Civil Code). How we proceed when dealing with insurers and why it pays to have a representative is described on the page why choose us for your compensation. The procedure after an accident is also summarised in our article on compensation for a traffic accident.
Low compensation from an insurer: summary
An insurer’s low offer is not final. Ask for a breakdown and justification, recalculate your claims according to the Supreme Court Methodology, add evidence and, if necessary, file an action. The sooner you start acting, the better you can secure evidence and watch the time limits. We will conduct the dispute with the compulsory motor insurer for you as part of our traffic accident compensation service. We assess your case free of charge, and you pay our fee only from the compensation recovered – more on the page what our service costs.
Submit your case online – the form takes just a few minutes. The next steps are described on the page how it works.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to accept low compensation from the insurer?
No. You can ask for a review and submit new evidence and your own expert opinion. If the insurer does not budge, seek the outstanding amount by an action.
By when must the insurer decide on my claim?
Under compulsory motor insurance, within 3 months of the claim. By then it must tell you the amount of compensation or explain in writing why it rejected or reduced the claim or has not completed the investigation. Compensation is payable within 15 days of the end of the investigation.
Do I waive the rest of my claim if I accept the amount paid?
Merely accepting the money usually does not. But beware of a settlement agreement or a declaration that you have been fully compensated – by signing it you may waive further claims. Have the document checked before signing.
Is my own expert opinion worth it?
Usually yes, if the insurer disputes the extent of the injury or of permanent consequences. An independent opinion is the strongest evidence for a review and for the court.
How much does an action against an insurer cost?
You pay no court fee for an action for compensation for injury to health. Expect the costs of an attorney and an expert; if you win the dispute and demanded payment from the insurer in advance, the court will usually award you reimbursement of these costs.
How long do I have to file an action?
A claim for compensation for injury to health becomes time-barred 3 years from when you learn of the harm and of who is liable for it. Negotiations with the insurer do not stop the time limit unless you have concluded an agreement on out-of-court negotiations.