Sometimes even all the care in the world does not prevent harm to a patient. If a medical procedure injures you, you ask who is liable for the harm – the doctor or the hospital – and on what basis. The law treats harm to health caused by an incorrect procedure like any other harm. We will explain the types of liability, the conditions, the burden of proof and the time limits so that you know from whom and how to claim compensation.
Short answer
Under civil law, the healthcare provider – the hospital, clinic or operator of the surgery – is liable to you for harm caused by incorrect treatment, including for its doctors and nurses (Section 2914 of the Civil Code). A doctor in employment is usually not directly liable to you. Liability arises from a breach of the duty to act lege artis, i.e. at the appropriate professional level (Section 2910 of the Civil Code, Section 4(5) of the Health Services Act). The provider is usually liable regardless of fault only for harm caused by a defective device or material.
In addition, a doctor may be criminally liable, for example for negligent bodily harm, and professionally liable before the Czech Medical Chamber. You must prove the breach of duty, the harm and the causal link; the courts take into account your difficult position in terms of evidence. You bring your claim within 3 years from when you learn of the harm and of the liable provider.
A doctor’s liability for harm and its types
When assessing liability for harm in medicine, we distinguish three levels. Each has a different purpose and a different addressee.
| Type of liability |
Who is liable |
What you get from it |
| Civil |
The healthcare provider |
Compensation for damage and non-material harm in money |
| Criminal |
The specific doctor, only if at fault |
Punishment of the person at fault; you can bring your claim for compensation in the criminal proceedings |
| Professional and administrative |
The doctor (Czech Medical Chamber), the provider (regional authority) |
Investigation of the procedure, disciplinary measure, fine |
Civil liability
An incorrect medical procedure harms your health and you acquire a claim for compensation for damage and reasonable satisfaction for non-material harm. The claim is based on the Civil Code. You claim:
- material damage – costs of further treatment, loss of earnings, lost profit,
- non-material harm – pain and suffering, loss of amenity, mental suffering and, in the event of death, the mental suffering of close persons.
You often hear that the provider is strictly liable and fault is not examined. It is not that simple. Courts assess ordinary care under Section 2910 of the Civil Code: the provider is liable if it breached the duty to act lege artis. The law usually presumes negligence, so the provider must prove that it acted correctly. It is usually liable regardless of fault only if the harm was caused by a defective thing, such as a defective implant or contaminated material.
You sue the provider, not the employee doctor. The provider is liable for its doctors, nurses and other staff as if it had caused the harm itself (Section 2914 of the Civil Code). If the doctor is the provider – typically a private doctor with their own surgery – they are liable to you directly. The specific claims you have and how to calculate them are discussed in the article on compensation for medical malpractice.
Criminal liability
The most serious errors, especially those with extensive consequences, can also be dealt with by a criminal complaint. Doctors most often face prosecution for:
- negligent homicide (Section 143 of the Criminal Code),
- negligent grievous bodily harm (Section 147 of the Criminal Code),
- negligent bodily harm (Section 148 of the Criminal Code).
Unlike civil liability, criminal liability is individual: it falls on the specific doctor and requires at least negligent fault.
Professional and administrative liability
The quality of healthcare services is also supervised by the Czech Medical Chamber; you can turn to it with a complaint about a doctor’s procedure. The provider may face proceedings for an administrative offence under the Health Services Act. These procedures will not bring you money, but their conclusions can serve as a basis for your claim.
Conditions for a doctor’s liability for harm
Breach of a legal duty
Staff must breach one of their duties. Most often this involves:
- a procedure contrary to the rules of science and recognised medical procedures (non lege artis),
- a procedure without informed consent – no one properly informed you of the risks,
- a breach of confidentiality,
- incomplete or incorrect records,
- neglect of care and supervision.
Harm
You must prove that the procedure harmed your health or otherwise affected your life: a deterioration of your condition, complications that would not have occurred with the correct procedure, prolonged treatment, pain, permanent consequences or the patient’s death.
Causal link
There must be a causal link between the breach of duty and the harm. In medical disputes this is usually the most difficult part: you must show that your health was harmed precisely by the error, not by the natural course of the illness.
How to bring a claim against the provider
Out-of-court solution. First, file a complaint directly with the provider; it must investigate it and inform you of the result. If you are not satisfied, contact the regional authority, the Czech Medical Chamber or your health insurance company. Also negotiate a settlement with the provider’s insurer – and if it offers little, read what to do when the insurer awards low compensation. Mediation can also be effective.
Pre-action demand. Before filing an action, send the provider a demand for voluntary payment. Without it, the court need not award you the costs of the proceedings.
Action. In the action you precisely quantify the material damage, state at least an approximate amount for non-material harm and attach records and expert reports. The course of the dispute is described in the article a lawsuit against a doctor.
Criminal proceedings. If criminal proceedings are being conducted against the doctor, you bring your claim directly in them and do not have to pay a court fee. File your claim at the latest at the main hearing before evidence is taken (Section 43(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure). How to do this is explained in our guide how to join criminal proceedings as an injured party.
The burden of proof in disputes with doctors
As the claimant, you prove the breach of duty, the harm and the causal link. But the courts take into account your objectively difficult position in terms of evidence. You usually do not have to prove the causal link with absolute certainty, and incomplete or inaccurate records may count against the provider.
Medical records. You have the right to inspect them and obtain extracts, transcripts or copies, or to appoint another person to do so. After a patient’s death, this right usually passes to their close persons.
Expert report. It decides whether the doctor acted according to the rules of science. You can obtain it from a privately chosen expert; the court may appoint its own, and you can also use reports from criminal proceedings or an autopsy.
Compensation for harm and its extent
Compensation for material damage includes medical costs not covered by health insurance, travel costs, care by close persons, medicines and aids, loss of earnings and lost profit. Non-material harm is compensated in money: pain and suffering, loss of amenity and other suffering. Courts no longer determine the amount according to points decrees but according to the principle of full compensation (Section 2958 of the Civil Code); the Supreme Court Methodology serves as a guide. If the patient dies, close persons are entitled to compensation for mental suffering, funeral costs and maintenance – see compensation for the consequences of death. Your health insurance company can also claim from the provider the treatment costs it incurred because of the error.
| What |
Value |
Provision |
| Limitation period |
3 years from when you learn of the harm and of who is liable for it |
Sections 620 and 629(1) of the Civil Code |
| Objective period of 10 or 15 years |
does not apply to harm to health and life – neither for material damage nor for non-material harm |
Section 636(3) of the Civil Code |
| Claim in criminal proceedings |
at the latest at the main hearing before evidence is taken |
Section 43(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure |
| Value of 1 point – health stabilised in 2026 |
usually CZK 492.15 |
Supreme Court Methodology |
Example: in January 2026 you learn that a complication after surgery was caused by a hospital error. Bring your claim by January 2029 at the latest – and start straight away, because an expert report takes months. Once your claim has been finally awarded, you usually have another ten years to enforce it.
What to do so you do not lose compensation
- Request a copy of your complete records. As soon as possible after the procedure.
- Keep notes. The course of treatment, pain, limitations, the names of doctors.
- Keep receipts and documents. Medicines, transport, care, lost earnings.
- Photograph the consequences. Regularly and with dates.
- Secure witnesses. Fellow patients, relatives who were present at conversations with doctors.
- Consult experts about the case. A lawyer experienced in medical law, a doctor of the same specialisation and a court-appointed expert.
- Check your legal expenses insurance. It may cover the costs of a lawyer and expert reports.
- Use patient organisations. They provide advice and support.
How providers defend themselves and why they cut compensation
Hospitals and their insurers most often claim that it was a complication that is one of the risks of the procedure and you were informed about it; that the harm was caused by the natural course of the illness; that an expert confirmed the procedure was lege artis; or that you did not follow the recommended treatment regime. An objection of time-bar is also common. You can counter each of them with complete records, your own expert report and a claim brought in time. We enforce compensation for patients with you from the complaint all the way to court.
Know your rights as an injured party
Asserting the rights of an injured patient is a demanding process that requires knowledge of the law, patience and often financial resources. Even so, it makes sense to assert your rights – not only for your own satisfaction, but also because these cases improve the quality and safety of healthcare. Courts are increasingly inclined to protect patients and take into account their complicated position in terms of evidence. We will assess your case free of charge, and you pay our fee only from the compensation recovered – more on the page how much the service costs.
Submit your case online – you can fill in the form in a few minutes. The next steps are described on the page how it works.
Frequently asked questions
Is the doctor or the hospital liable for an error?
Under civil law, usually the hospital or other healthcare provider, including for its employees (Section 2914 of the Civil Code). A private doctor who is the provider is liable directly. Criminally, it is always the specific doctor who is liable.
Do I have to prove that the doctor erred intentionally?
No. Under civil law, a breach of the duty to act lege artis is sufficient; the law usually presumes negligence. You prove the error, the harm and the causal link.
What does a procedure lege artis mean?
Providing healthcare services at the appropriate professional level, i.e. according to the rules of science and recognised medical procedures, respecting the patient’s individuality, taking into account the specific conditions and objective possibilities (Section 4(5) of the Health Services Act).
Is every complication after surgery a medical error?
No. A complication that is one of the risks of the procedure and about which the doctor properly informed you need not be an error. What matters is whether the doctor acted correctly and whether they informed you of the risks.
Can I file a criminal complaint against a doctor?
Yes, in the case of a serious error, typically for negligent bodily harm or negligent homicide. In criminal proceedings you can also bring a claim for compensation, at the latest at the main hearing before evidence is taken.
By when must I bring my claim?
Within 3 years from when you learn of the harm and of who is liable for it. The objective periods of 10 and 15 years do not apply to harm to health and life (Section 636(3) of the Civil Code).