Errors in the provision of healthcare often have serious consequences for the patient. If a doctor has harmed your health and the hospital refuses liability or offers little, you have the right to seek compensation for damage and reasonable satisfaction in court. We will take you through the lawsuit step by step: whom to sue, what you must prove, how the proceedings work, which time limits to watch and what costs to expect.
Short answer
You file the action against the healthcare provider – the hospital, clinic or operator of the surgery. The provider is liable for its doctors and nurses as if it had caused the harm itself (Section 2914 of the Civil Code), so you usually do not sue the employee doctor. At least 7 days before filing the action, send the provider a demand for payment, otherwise the court need not award you the costs of the proceedings (Section 142a of the Code of Civil Procedure). At first instance, the district court usually decides (Section 9(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure).
In the proceedings you prove a breach of the duty to act lege artis, the harm and the causal link. The law presumes negligence (Section 2911 of the Civil Code), and the outcome of the dispute is usually decided by the expert report. File the action within 3 years from when you learn of the harm and of who is liable for it (Sections 620 and 629(1) of the Civil Code). The objective periods of 10 and 15 years do not apply to harm to health (Section 636(3)).
When it makes sense to sue a doctor or a hospital
You can always file an action, but it only makes sense if the doctor or hospital actually made an error and you suffered harm as a result. Medicine works with risk: a complication about which the doctor properly informed you and which occurred despite the correct procedure need not be an error. The table summarises the most common reasons for disputes.
| Reason for the action |
Typical situation |
| Procedure non lege artis |
The doctor did not follow the rules of science and recognised medical procedures, for example overlooked an obvious finding. |
| Wrong or delayed diagnosis |
Because it was detected late, the illness developed into a more serious stage. |
| Error during a procedure |
Damage to an organ or nerve that is not one of the unavoidable risks of the procedure. |
| Medication error |
The wrong drug, an incorrect dose or an unsuitable combination of drugs. |
| Neglect of care and supervision |
A missed examination, a fall by a restless patient, an overlooked infection. |
| Lack of informed consent |
The doctor did not inform you of the risks and alternatives of treatment, and the risk materialised. |
| Breach of confidentiality |
Staff disclosed information about your health to an unauthorised person. |
Whom you sue and on what basis
The defendant is the healthcare provider. If you were treated by a private doctor with their own surgery, they are the provider themselves and you sue them directly. A doctor in employment is usually not directly liable to you; the hospital is liable for them (Section 2914 of the Civil Code). We discuss who is liable for a medical error in detail in a separate article.
You often read online that a hospital is strictly liable and the court does not examine fault. In general, this is not true. The court assesses ordinary care under Section 2910 of the Civil Code: the provider is liable if it breached the duty to provide care at the appropriate professional level, i.e. according to the rules of science and recognised medical procedures (Section 4(5) of the Health Services Act). But your position is strengthened by a statutory presumption: if the provider breached a statutory duty, it is presumed to have acted negligently (Section 2911). It must prove the opposite. It is liable regardless of fault for damage caused by a defective thing, such as a defective implant or contaminated material. The law expressly applies this to healthcare services as well (Section 2936).
What you must prove in court
- A breach of duty – the doctor did not act lege artis, did not inform you of the risks or neglected care.
- Harm – damage to health, pain, permanent consequences, costs or loss of earnings.
- A causal link – the harm was caused precisely by the error, not by the natural course of the illness.
You do not have to prove fault; the law presumes negligence. The causal link is usually the most difficult. In disputes with doctors, courts take into account your difficult position in terms of evidence: you usually do not have to prove the causal link with absolute certainty, and incomplete or inaccurate records may count against the provider. But you cannot rely on this – without an expert report you will usually not win the dispute.
Before you file an action
A lawsuit costs time and money, so it is preceded by careful preparation. What to do straight after the procedure is described in our guide what to do if you suspect medical malpractice. Before filing an action, go through these steps:
- Medical records. You have the right to inspect them and obtain extracts, transcripts or copies. Ask for them in writing and keep proof that you sent the request.
- Independent professional assessment. A doctor of the same specialisation or an expert witness will tell you whether the dispute has a chance. Without their opinion you do not know what you are getting into.
- Complaint. The provider, the regional authority and the Czech Medical Chamber can investigate the procedure and discipline the doctor. But they will not award you money; you use their conclusions as evidence.
- Settlement negotiations. Providers usually have liability insurance. The insurer often prefers to negotiate a settlement rather than risk a dispute. If it offers little, read what to do when the insurer awards low compensation.
- Demand for payment. Send it to the provider by registered post at least 7 days before filing the action, stating what you are claiming and how much.
In these disputes you practically cannot do without a lawyer. The key decision comes before the action: is the dispute worth it at all? It makes no sense to invest years and money in a dispute that has no chance of success. Why we are the right people to help you with this decision is explained on the page why deal with compensation with us.
The lawsuit step by step
Proceedings for compensation against a healthcare provider go through these stages:
| Stage |
What happens |
Time limit and provision |
| 1. Demand for payment |
You ask the provider to pay voluntarily. |
at least 7 days before the action, Section 142a CCP |
| 2. Filing the action |
You file the action with the court of first instance. |
usually the district court, Section 9(1) CCP |
| 3. Defendant’s response |
The court serves the action on the provider and asks it to respond. |
the court sets the time limit |
| 4. Taking of evidence |
Examination of the parties and witnesses, records, expert reports and examination of experts. |
usually the longest stage of the dispute |
| 5. First-instance judgment |
The court grants the action, grants it in part or dismisses it. |
– |
| 6. Appeal |
The regional court decides on the appeal. |
usually 15 days from service of the judgment |
| 7. Appeal on points of law |
An extraordinary remedy; the Supreme Court decides. |
usually 2 months from service of the appellate court’s decision |
The action
A good action decides the whole dispute. Describe the course of treatment chronologically with exact dates, identify where the doctor erred and refer to specific parts of the records. Quantify the material damage precisely according to the documents. For non-material harm, state the amount claimed and justify it – the court determines it according to the principle of full compensation (Section 2958 of the Civil Code). As evidence, identify the records, expert reports, witnesses from your family and from among the staff, photographs and correspondence.
The expert report
In disputes with doctors, the expert decides. You can commission a report yourself before filing the action: you choose the expert and know in advance what chance the dispute has. The disadvantage is the cost. The court may appoint its own expert, especially if the parties’ reports contradict each other. You can also use reports from criminal proceedings. Have the expert’s conclusions evaluated – the expert assesses the medical side; the court draws the legal consequences.
Length of the proceedings
Disputes with doctors are among the longest. Because of the expert evidence, first-instance proceedings often take several years, longer with an appeal. That is why it makes sense to negotiate a settlement at the same time – you can conclude an agreement with the provider or its insurer at any stage of the dispute.
What you can claim in the action – and how much
In the action you bring all the claims the error caused you:
- Pain and suffering – for pain from the harm to health, treatment and dealing with the consequences. More in the article on pain and suffering.
- Loss of amenity – for permanent consequences that limit you at work, in your family and in your hobbies. See loss of amenity.
- Other non-material harm – for example particularly intense mental suffering (Sections 2956 and 2958 of the Civil Code).
- Loss of earnings during sick leave and after it ends (Sections 2962 and 2963).
- Healthcare costs not covered by health insurance (Section 2960).
- Claims of surviving relatives – if the patient dies, close persons are entitled to compensation for mental suffering, funeral costs and maintenance. See compensation for the consequences of death.
Courts determine the amount of pain and suffering and loss of amenity according to the Supreme Court Methodology. The point value equals 1% of the average gross monthly wage for the year preceding the year in which your health stabilised.
| Item |
Health stabilised in 2026 |
| Value of 1 pain point |
usually CZK 492.15 |
| Base amount for loss of amenity |
400 times the average wage, i.e. CZK 19,686,000 |
| Basic amount of loss of amenity |
percentage of impairment × base amount, then adjusted for age and other circumstances |
Model example: after an incorrectly performed operation, the expert assesses your pain at 300 points and your permanent consequences at 10% impairment. Pain and suffering is then usually CZK 147,645 (300 × CZK 492.15), and the basic amount of loss of amenity CZK 1,968,600 – before adjustment for your age and other circumstances. This illustrates the calculation and is not a promise of results.
What the dispute costs and who pays the costs
Expect costs for a lawyer and expert reports. You do not pay a court fee for an action for compensation for harm to health – the claimant is exempt (Section 11(2)(d) of the Court Fees Act); a fee is payable only for claims unrelated to harm to health, for example for a breach of confidentiality alone. Whoever succeeds in the dispute is usually awarded the costs of the proceedings against the unsuccessful party. For an action for payment, however, there is a condition: you must send the demand for payment at least 7 days before filing the action. Without it, the court will award you costs only exceptionally, for reasons deserving special consideration (Section 142a(2) CCP). If you lose the dispute, you usually pay the other side’s costs.
If criminal proceedings are being conducted against the doctor, you can bring your claim for compensation directly in them. File your claim at the latest at the main hearing before evidence is taken (Section 43(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure). If the criminal court awards the claim only in part or acquits the defendant, it will refer you to civil proceedings for the rest of the claim (Section 229 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The procedure is explained in our guide how to join criminal proceedings as an injured party.
What to do so you do not lose compensation
- Watch the limitation period. Three years run from when you learn of the harm and of the liable provider.
- Request your complete records. Ideally before filing a complaint.
- Have the case assessed in advance. By an independent doctor or expert, before filing an action.
- Keep documents. Medicines, transport, aids, care by loved ones. You can also ask the provider for a reasonable advance on healthcare costs (Section 2960 of the Civil Code).
- Keep a diary. Pain, limitations, visits to doctors – with dates.
- Send a demand for payment. At least 7 days before the action, by registered post.
- Do not sign a premature settlement. Only conclude a “final” agreement once your health has stabilised.
How hospitals defend themselves in a dispute and why they cut compensation
Providers and their insurers repeat the same arguments:
- “It was a complication we informed you about.” What matters is whether the doctor informed you properly and acted correctly.
- “The harm was caused by the illness, not the treatment.” You counter this with an expert report on the causal link.
- Contributory fault. You did not follow the treatment regime or missed a check-up – the court then reduces compensation proportionately (Section 2918 of the Civil Code).
- Time-bar. An action filed after three years will usually fail if the provider raises the objection of time-bar.
- An exaggerated amount. The insurer disputes the number of points or the percentage of impairment and offers a lower sum.
You can counter every objection with complete records, your own expert report and an action filed in time. We enforce compensation for patients with you from the demand for payment to a final judgment.
You do not have to fight the hospital alone
A lawsuit against a doctor or hospital requires careful preparation, professional guidance and patience. Do not pursue it as an act of revenge, but as a way to obtain compensation for real harm – often also as an impulse to improve care for other patients. Before starting a dispute, have its chances realistically assessed. We will assess your case free of charge, and you pay our fee only from the compensation recovered – more on the page how much the service costs.
Submit your case online – you can fill in the form in a few minutes. The next steps are described on the page how it works.
Frequently asked questions
Whom should I sue – the doctor or the hospital?
Usually the healthcare provider, i.e. the hospital or the operator of the surgery. It is liable for doctors and nurses as if it had caused the harm itself (Section 2914 of the Civil Code). You sue a private doctor who is the provider directly.
Must I send a demand for payment before filing an action?
Yes, if you want the costs of the proceedings after winning. Send the demand at least 7 days before filing the action (Section 142a of the Code of Civil Procedure). Without it, the court will award you costs only exceptionally.
Do I have to prove that the doctor erred intentionally?
No. You prove a breach of the duty to act lege artis, the harm and the causal link. The law presumes negligence (Section 2911 of the Civil Code), and the provider must prove the opposite.
How long does a lawsuit against a hospital take?
Usually several years, because the court needs expert reports. You can conclude a settlement with the provider or its insurer at any stage of the proceedings.
What if I lose the dispute?
Then you usually pay the other side’s costs of the proceedings, including its lawyer’s costs. That is why you should have your chances assessed in advance, ideally on the basis of an expert report.
By when must I file the action?
Within 3 years from when you learn of the harm and of who is liable for it (Sections 620 and 629(1) of the Civil Code). The objective periods of 10 and 15 years do not apply to harm to health (Section 636(3)).