Delays in proceedings and compensation

Free case assessment
Are you entitled to compensation?
  • Contact us and we will help you
or call +420 773 014 007

Delays in proceedings are one of the most common reasons why people claim compensation from the state. Your right to have your case heard without undue delay is guaranteed by the Czech constitutional order and by international treaties. We explain when proceedings are unreasonably long, how much the state can pay you and how to bring your claim.

If court or administrative proceedings take unreasonably long, the state is liable to you for maladministration under Section 13(1) of Act No. 82/1998 Coll. It owes you reasonable satisfaction for non-material harm and, where applicable, compensation for damage. The amount depends on the overall length and complexity of the proceedings, your conduct, the conduct of the authorities and the importance of the matter for you (Section 31a(3)).

The Supreme Court recommends a baseline amount of CZK 15,000 to 20,000 for each year of proceedings, with the first two years at half rate. You bring the claim with the Ministry of Justice (delays by a court) or with the competent ministry (delays by an authority), at the latest within 6 months of the end of the proceedings – you can do so already while they are running.

Protection against delays is rooted in the highest-ranking sources of law. A decision in your case without undue delay is your fundamental human right. You can find it in these provisions:

Provision What it lays down
Article 38(2) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms The right to have your case heard without undue delay
Article 6(1) of the European Convention on Human Rights The right to have your case heard within a reasonable time
Section 13(1) of Act No. 82/1998 Coll. A breach of the duty to decide within a reasonable time is maladministration
Section 31a(3) of Act No. 82/1998 Coll. The criteria for the amount of satisfaction for delays

Decisions of the highest courts

The highest courts have further elaborated the intensity of the interference with your rights. Their decisions show that:

  • delays are situations in which proceedings exceed a reasonable length,
  • each case is assessed individually, examining whether the delays were caused by the court or the authority,
  • courts always consider whether the delays were caused by the party to the proceedings themselves,
  • the state cannot excuse itself by the overload of the judiciary or by its organisation – it is responsible for how it organises proceedings.

Courts usually assess the overall length of proceedings from their start to their final conclusion, including all instances. Related administrative and court proceedings may be assessed as one whole.

In its opinion Cpjn 206/2010, the Supreme Court unified the calculation of satisfaction. It set the baseline amount at CZK 15,000 to 20,000 for each year of proceedings, with the first two years calculated at half rate. The court then adjusts this according to the criteria of Section 31a(3).

Case law of the Supreme Administrative Court

For administrative authorities, the Supreme Administrative Court defines the criteria for assessing inaction, the conditions for a successful action for protection against inaction and the statutory time limits for issuing a decision. Against inaction by an administrative authority, you first defend yourself with a request for measures against inaction with the superior authority; only if you are unsuccessful do you file an action with the administrative court. If the authority did not decide at all within the statutory time limit, read our guide to compensation for state inaction too.

Compensation for delays in proceedings

Compensation for delays works as a remedial tool: the state reasonably compensates you for the harm caused by long proceedings. Delays are a special form of maladministration. Compensation includes these components:

  • Actual damage – a direct decrease in your assets because of the delays.
  • Lost profit – income you lost because of the delays. Example: a court takes so long to decide on your claim that the debtor goes bankrupt in the meantime and you can no longer recover the money. However, you must prove the link between the delays and the loss, which is often difficult.
  • Satisfaction for non-material harm – uncertainty, mental suffering and stress from long proceedings. For delays, this is the most common and most easily provable item.
  • Costs of proceedings – reasonable costs of remedying the delays, for example of an application for setting a time limit (Section 31). However, the state does not pay the costs of an attorney for the ministry’s assessment of the claim (Section 31(4)).

Whether you pay tax on the compensation is explained in our article on taxation of compensation for non-material harm.

How to claim compensation for delays in proceedings

Compensation from the state follows a strict procedure. Some claims have a very short time limit (6 months), so deal with the situation as soon as possible.

1. Preliminary assessment of the claim

You first bring the claim before the competent authority. For delays by a court, this is the Ministry of Justice; for delays by an administrative authority, the ministry or central authority to which the authority belongs (Section 6). If the state assesses related administrative and court proceedings as one whole, it is represented by the authority from the field in which the administrative proceedings took place (Section 6(3)). The preliminary assessment is a necessary condition for an action (Section 14(3)).

In the application, state the file number of the proceedings, a timeline with the periods of inactivity, a description of the impact on your life and the amount claimed, with a calculation according to the Supreme Court’s opinion. Attach the documents and your bank account number. The law does not require a prescribed form for delays.

2. Court proceedings

If the authority does not satisfy your claim in full within 6 months of bringing it, you file an action with the locally competent court (Section 15(2)). In the proceedings, you prove that the state breached its duty to decide within a reasonable time and quantify the total amount of the harm. The same authority that assessed the claim acts for the state in court (Section 6(7)).

How much you get: calculating satisfaction in figures

We show the calculation under opinion Cpjn 206/2010 on model proceedings that lasted 8 years, with a baseline amount of CZK 15,000 per year:

Period Rate Amount
1st and 2nd year half, CZK 7,500/year CZK 15,000
3rd to 8th year CZK 15,000/year CZK 90,000
Basis   CZK 105,000
At a rate of CZK 20,000/year CZK 10,000 + CZK 20,000/year CZK 140,000

The court then adjusts the basis according to the criteria of Section 31a(3):

Criterion Increases compensation Reduces compensation
Complexity of the proceedings A simple matter Several instances, experts, a foreign element
Your conduct You actively sped up the proceedings You caused the delays yourself or did not use the means against them
Conduct of the authorities Long periods of inactivity Smooth progress
Importance of the matter for you Childcare, health, an employment dispute, a criminal case A trivial dispute

Model examples of delays in proceedings

Example 1 – building proceedings: the proceedings last 4 years without a decision and the building authority repeatedly asks for additional documentation. The investor cannot start construction and the project becomes more expensive. If the requests for additional documents were not justified, the investor can claim compensation for the increased costs and satisfaction for the unreasonable length of the proceedings – four years is usually unreasonable for standard building proceedings.

Example 2 – criminal proceedings: criminal proceedings concerning an attack in which you were injured last 8 years, and the whole time you wait for a decision on compensation. If you joined the proceedings as an injured party with a claim for compensation, you too are usually entitled to satisfaction for the delays. How long the individual stages usually take is described in our article on how long proceedings for compensation take.

What to do so that you do not lose your compensation

  1. Keep a timeline of the proceedings. Dates of submissions, hearings, decisions and periods when nothing happened.
  2. Fight delays already during the proceedings. In court, file an application for setting a time limit for a procedural step; with an authority, a request for measures against inaction.
  3. Do not cause delays yourself. Adjournments at your request or late submissions will reduce your compensation.
  4. Record the impact on your life. Stress, health problems, lost opportunities – and supporting documents, for example medical reports or correspondence with business partners.
  5. Bring your claim at the latest within 6 months of the end of the proceedings. You can also do so earlier, during the proceedings.
  6. Quantify your claim according to opinion Cpjn 206/2010. The ministry will then find it hard to offer less without justification.
  7. If the claim is not fully satisfied within 6 months, file an action.

Why the state reduces compensation for delays

The ministry most often argues that the proceedings were complex, that you contributed to their length yourself or did not use the means against delays, or that the matter was not very important for you. For shorter delays and trivial disputes, it often offers only a finding of a violation of rights instead of money (Section 31a(2)). This is mainly considered where the length of the proceedings exceeded a reasonable limit only slightly, or where the matter was not very important for you. A well-documented timeline will help you counter each of these objections. If you need advice on compensation for damage caused by the state, we will take over communication with the ministry and any court dispute for you.

The rights of the injured party

Successfully claiming compensation for delays requires consistent documentation of the course of the proceedings, an active approach to protecting your rights, knowledge of case law, correct quantification and quality legal representation. Our service was created as a tool for injured parties in the fight against injustice. We assess your case free of charge, and you pay our fee only from the compensation recovered – more on the page what our service costs.

Submit your case online – the form takes just a few minutes. The next steps are described on the page how it works.

Frequently asked questions

When are proceedings unreasonably long?

There is no fixed limit. What matters is the overall length of the proceedings, their complexity, your conduct, the conduct of the courts and authorities and the importance of the matter for you (Section 31a(3) of Act No. 82/1998 Coll.). Four-year standard building proceedings or waiting several years for a court hearing are usually unreasonable.

How much will the state pay me for delays?

The Supreme Court recommends a baseline amount of CZK 15,000 to 20,000 for each year of proceedings, with the first two years at half rate. For proceedings lasting 8 years, the basis is CZK 105,000 to 140,000, which the court further adjusts according to the circumstances.

Do I have to wait until the proceedings end?

No. You can bring your claim already during the proceedings. Bring it at the latest within 6 months of the end of the proceedings, otherwise the claim for satisfaction becomes time-barred (Section 32(3)).

Where do I bring my claim?

For delays by a court, with the Ministry of Justice. For delays by an administrative authority, with the ministry or central authority to which the authority belongs. You can sue if it does not satisfy your claim in full within 6 months.

Am I also entitled as an injured party in criminal proceedings?

Usually yes, if you joined the proceedings with a claim for compensation for damage or harm. The length of the criminal proceedings then also interferes with your right to have your case heard within a reasonable time.

What if I partly caused the delays myself?

The state and the court will take this into account and reduce the compensation (Section 31a(3)(c)). They will also reduce it if you did not use the available means against delays, for example an application for setting a time limit.

More interesting posts from this section

Limitation of a compensation claim: time limits

Limitation of a compensation claim: time limits

A claim for compensation is not valid forever. If you do not bring it in time, the wrongdoer or their insurer will raise a limitation defence and the court will not award you compensation – even if you are right about everything else. And the period runs even when nothing seems to be happening: during treatment, while corresponding with the insurer or while waiting for a criminal judgment. What you can claim from the wrongdoer is summarised in the overview of claims for harm to health.

Annuity after an injury

Annuity after an injury

Your incapacity for work has ended, but after the injury you will not return to your former job – or only part-time, for lower pay or with a strain you never knew before. The wrongdoer usually does not make up the difference in one payment: the Civil Code provides for this loss with a regular monthly payment, an annuity. Over ten or twenty years it may even exceed pain and suffering, yet injured people often lose it – for example by signing a settlement “in full”.

Reference

Marek S.
I suffered an accident at work and it was only through legal aid that I was able to find out what I could claim from my employer. I therefore claimed from my employer for reimbursement of medical expenses, compensation for wages during incapacity for work and a subsequent annuity. My employer also paid me severance pay, which I never thought would be such a large sum.
Daniel N.
I contacted this company for help. I thought I was entitled to severance pay due to my medical condition and occupational illness, but my employer claimed I was not entitled to anything. Fortunately, I didn't take their arrogance lying down, and thanks to their help, they paid me severance pay and are still paying me an annuity due to my occupational illness. Thank you very much.
Petr H.
Thank you for your service and help in a difficult situation with my employer. I have dealt with unpaid compensation from my employer when travelling abroad for work. In the end we resolved everything. Thanks for your help, willingness, determination, and most importantly motivation to not give up just out of fear of being in a weaker position.
Jana S.
I got fired when I was pregnant at the time. I thought that was a valid notice. Fortunately, I took advice on the situation and was not left destitute and unsecured, thank you so much for your human touch, empathy and discretion in handling the whole matter.
Martin F.
Thank you so much for helping me with a problem at work. It was about the payment of wage compensation during and after the treatment period. If it wasn't for you, I wouldn't have known I was entitled to anything like that. I am glad I sought information and chose your services. I don't wish anyone to experience such things, but if you already run into some problems, don't hesitate to choose the help of professionals, they are the people in their place.
    Advokátní kancelář Šmarda s.r.o.

    Jindrisska
    Masarykova třída 922/8, Prague

    Do not miss anything important

    Sign up for our newsletter