Compensation for damage caused by maladministration

Free case assessment
Are you entitled to compensation?
  • Contact us and we will help you
or call +420 773 014 007

Maladministration is one of the most common causes of state liability for damage. We show you what counts as maladministration, what you can claim from the state and how to proceed so that you actually obtain compensation.

Maladministration is a failure by an authority, a court, the police or another state body that is not reflected in the content of a decision – for example a lost file, an incorrect entry in a register, incorrect instructions, a disproportionate intervention, inaction or delays. The state is strictly liable for it under Section 13 of Act No. 82/1998 Coll. You do not have to prove the annulment of a decision or fault on the part of the official.

You bring your claim before the ministry or central authority whose competence the matter falls under – for courts and criminal proceedings, the Ministry of Justice. You can sue if the authority does not satisfy the claim in full within 6 months. A claim for damages becomes time-barred 3 years from when you learn of the damage and of who is liable for it; a claim for satisfaction for non-material harm just 6 months from when you learn of the harm.

What maladministration is

Think of maladministration as failures by state bodies in their ordinary official activity. It concerns not only civil servants, but also courts, police officers, customs officers and other bodies exercising state power. The typical forms are summarised in the table:

Failure Example from practice
Delays in proceedings A court does not schedule a hearing for a year
Breach of a statutory time limit, inaction An authority does not issue a decision within the statutory time limit
Incorrect record-keeping An incorrect entry in the land register or a public register
Loss of or damage to a file An authority loses your original documents
Incorrect instructions An authority tells you the wrong time limit for an appeal
Disproportionate intervention The police use clearly disproportionate force

We have separate guides for the two most common forms: delays in proceedings and state inaction.

Note: if the error lies in the content of a decision – the authority applies the wrong law or gives insufficient reasons for the decision – it is not maladministration, but an unlawful decision. There, you must first have the decision annulled by a remedy.

Protection against maladministration is found in the highest-ranking legislation. The basis is Article 36(3) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms.

Detailed rules are set out in Act No. 82/1998 Coll., on liability for damage caused in the exercise of public power. Under Section 13(1), the state is liable for damage caused by maladministration. This expressly includes a breach of the duty to perform an act or issue a decision within the statutory time limit or, where the law does not set one, within a reasonable time. The same rules also apply to other cases of damage caused by the state.

Conditions of state liability for damage

  1. Maladministration – an act, conduct or intervention by a state body that interfered with your rights.
  2. Damage or non-material harm – the conduct caused you financial or non-material harm.
  3. Causal link – there is a close and provable connection between the conduct and the harm.

These three conditions establish the state’s liability. The next step is quantification: the state and, if necessary, the court will examine the extent of your harm and decide on reasonable compensation. Compared with an unlawful decision, maladministration has three advantages:

  • you do not need a decision to be annulled first,
  • you do not prove fault – liability is strict,
  • the state cannot escape liability.

The scope of compensation

Financial damage caused by maladministration

Item What it includes
Actual damage A direct decrease in your assets and the costs you incurred to mitigate the consequences
Lost profit The benefit you would have obtained without the failure, including lost business opportunities
Costs of proceedings Reasonable costs of remedying the maladministration, including an attorney at the statutory tariff (Section 31)

What matters for an award of compensation is whether the damage actually arose as a result of the state’s maladministration. Damage is often the result of several factors combined, so the state and the court look for its essential cause.

Example – damage: the state unlawfully blocks the import of goods. The trader could sell the goods in another EU member state, but waits idly for the obstacle to be removed and the goods spoil in the meantime. The state will usually not compensate the part of the damage the trader could reasonably have prevented.

Non-material harm caused by maladministration

  • Interference with personality rights – for example, when the police handcuff you in a degrading way during an intervention or “kneel” on you.
  • Psychological harm – damage to mental health, trauma after an intervention.
  • Damage to your good reputation – an intervention by the customs administration damages your name with business partners.
  • Interference with family life.

You receive monetary satisfaction if a finding of a violation of rights is not enough. The amount corresponds to the seriousness of the harm and the circumstances in which it arose (Section 31a(2)). If the police also restricted your liberty, read our article on unlawful detention by the police too.

Example – harm: if you resisted the intervention and repeatedly disobeyed instructions, it will be difficult to succeed in a dispute over harm caused by the use of coercive means. It is different if the force used was clearly disproportionate to the situation.

The total compensation is the sum of all items. The state or the court may reduce each of them, and exceptionally increase it, depending on the circumstances of the case. Whether you pay tax on the compensation is explained in our article on taxation of compensation for non-material harm.

Claiming compensation for damage caused by the state

1. Preliminary assessment of the claim

You first bring the claim before the authority under Section 6 of the Act: for courts and criminal proceedings, the Ministry of Justice; in administrative matters, the ministry or central authority whose competence the matter falls under; if it cannot be determined, the Ministry of Finance. The authority assesses the claim and decides whether to pay you compensation out of court. Without this step you cannot file an action (Section 14(3)).

In the application, state who you are, which body failed and when, what damage or harm this caused you, how much you claim and how you calculated the amount. Attach the evidence and your bank account number. The law requires a prescribed form only for claims for custody and sentences (Section 14(6)); otherwise you write the application in free form.

2. Court proceedings

If the authority does not satisfy the claim in full within 6 months, you go to court (Section 15(2)). The same authority that assessed the claim acts for the state in court (Section 6(7)). A damages dispute is legally complex and can take years, so always consider whether going to court is worth it. The Constitutional Court has repeatedly pointed out that courts must respect the constitutional origin of these claims in Article 36(3) of the Charter. If they placed an impossible burden of proof on the claimant, they would make the right to compensation illusory.

The time limits and figures that matter

What Time limit Provision
Handling of the claim by the authority 6 months from bringing the claim Section 15
Limitation of a claim for damages 3 years from learning of the damage and of who is liable for it Section 32(1)
Limitation of a claim for non-material harm 6 months from learning of the harm, at most 10 years Section 32(3)
For delays and inaction A claim for non-material harm does not become time-barred earlier than 6 months after the proceedings end Section 32(3), second sentence
Suspension of limitation During the preliminary assessment, for at most 6 months Section 35(1)

Example: on 10 January 2026 the police injure and humiliate you during an intervention. Bring your claim for satisfaction for non-material harm with the ministry, as a rule, by 10 July 2026. If you send the application only in August, the state will plead the statute of limitations. You can claim damages – for example a destroyed phone or lost earnings – by 10 January 2029.

What to do so that you do not lose your compensation

The best prevention of damage is an active approach already during the proceedings: follow their course, use remedies in time, communicate with the authority and document its actions.

  1. Document the failure. Keep a record of your communication with the authority, keep delivery receipts, e-mails and notes from inspecting the file.
  2. Use the means of redress. A complaint about the authority’s conduct, a complaint about police conduct, an application to the court for setting a time limit, a request for measures against inaction.
  3. Mitigate the damage. Do not wait idly – the state will not compensate what you could have prevented.
  4. Quantify the damage objectively. Lost profit is most often proven by an expert opinion.
  5. Prove the non-material harm. Medical and psychological reports, witnesses, photographs of injuries.
  6. Bring your claim within 6 months. This also covers the shortest limitation period.
  7. If the claim is not fully satisfied within 6 months, file an action.

Why the state reduces or refuses compensation

Ministries most often argue that the error lies in the content of a decision (and so it is not maladministration), that there is no causal link, that you contributed to the damage yourself – you disobeyed an instruction, you did not mitigate the damage – or that a finding of a violation of rights is sufficient satisfaction. A plea of limitation regarding non-material harm is also common. The state will not reimburse the costs of an attorney for the ministry’s assessment of the claim (Section 31(4)). That is why we prepare the recovery of compensation for damage caused by the state with you so that it also stands up in court.

The rights of the injured party

Compensation for damage caused by maladministration is a complex legal issue. You will succeed if you know the legal framework, carefully document the failure, prepare the documents precisely and react in time. We will help you with that. We assess your case free of charge, and you pay our fee only from the compensation recovered – more on the page what our service costs.

Submit your case online – the form takes just a few minutes. The next steps are described on the page how it works.

Frequently asked questions

What counts as maladministration?

Any failure by a state body in its official activity that is not reflected in the content of a decision: a lost file, an incorrect entry in a register, incorrect instructions, a disproportionate police intervention, inaction and delays in proceedings.

What is the difference between maladministration and an unlawful decision?

An unlawful decision is an error in the content of a decision, and you must first have it annulled by a remedy. Maladministration is an error in the authority’s activity outside the content of a decision, and no decision needs to be annulled.

Do I have to prove that the official acted intentionally?

No. The state’s liability is strict, regardless of fault, and it cannot escape it. You prove the failure, the damage or harm and the causal link.

Where do I bring my claim?

For courts and criminal proceedings, with the Ministry of Justice. In administrative matters, with the ministry or central authority whose competence the matter falls under. If the competent authority cannot be determined, with the Ministry of Finance.

By when must I bring my claim?

A claim for damages becomes time-barred 3 years from learning of the damage and the liable party. A claim for satisfaction for non-material harm becomes time-barred after just 6 months. By bringing the claim with the ministry, you suspend limitation for the duration of the assessment, for at most 6 months.

Will I get compensation for stress and humiliation too?

Yes, if the harm reaches a certain level of seriousness and a mere finding of a violation of rights would not be enough. The state will then provide reasonable satisfaction in money under Section 31a of Act No. 82/1998 Coll.

More interesting posts from this section

Limitation of a compensation claim: time limits

Limitation of a compensation claim: time limits

A claim for compensation is not valid forever. If you do not bring it in time, the wrongdoer or their insurer will raise a limitation defence and the court will not award you compensation – even if you are right about everything else. And the period runs even when nothing seems to be happening: during treatment, while corresponding with the insurer or while waiting for a criminal judgment. What you can claim from the wrongdoer is summarised in the overview of claims for harm to health.

Annuity after an injury

Annuity after an injury

Your incapacity for work has ended, but after the injury you will not return to your former job – or only part-time, for lower pay or with a strain you never knew before. The wrongdoer usually does not make up the difference in one payment: the Civil Code provides for this loss with a regular monthly payment, an annuity. Over ten or twenty years it may even exceed pain and suffering, yet injured people often lose it – for example by signing a settlement “in full”.

Reference

Marek S.
I suffered an accident at work and it was only through legal aid that I was able to find out what I could claim from my employer. I therefore claimed from my employer for reimbursement of medical expenses, compensation for wages during incapacity for work and a subsequent annuity. My employer also paid me severance pay, which I never thought would be such a large sum.
Daniel N.
I contacted this company for help. I thought I was entitled to severance pay due to my medical condition and occupational illness, but my employer claimed I was not entitled to anything. Fortunately, I didn't take their arrogance lying down, and thanks to their help, they paid me severance pay and are still paying me an annuity due to my occupational illness. Thank you very much.
Petr H.
Thank you for your service and help in a difficult situation with my employer. I have dealt with unpaid compensation from my employer when travelling abroad for work. In the end we resolved everything. Thanks for your help, willingness, determination, and most importantly motivation to not give up just out of fear of being in a weaker position.
Jana S.
I got fired when I was pregnant at the time. I thought that was a valid notice. Fortunately, I took advice on the situation and was not left destitute and unsecured, thank you so much for your human touch, empathy and discretion in handling the whole matter.
Martin F.
Thank you so much for helping me with a problem at work. It was about the payment of wage compensation during and after the treatment period. If it wasn't for you, I wouldn't have known I was entitled to anything like that. I am glad I sought information and chose your services. I don't wish anyone to experience such things, but if you already run into some problems, don't hesitate to choose the help of professionals, they are the people in their place.
    Advokátní kancelář Šmarda s.r.o.

    Jindrisska
    Masarykova třída 922/8, Prague

    Do not miss anything important

    Sign up for our newsletter